Bearing comparison

Our hubs are now offered with a wide choice of high quality bearing sets, you can read here the comparison between different kind of bearings.

 

Replacing cartridge bearings is not as simple as it seems.

Removing a Worn-out Bearing
In most cases, when you have to extract a hub bearing you can only pull it by its internal race. This operation will generally damage or compromise bearing races, however if you are going to replace a worn-out bearing with a new one this is a marginal problem.


Removing a Bearing that's Still Good
In case you have to re-install a previously-used bearing, avoid hitting the internal race with a mallet. Even threaded extractors or a press can damage bearing balls and races. Try to warm up the hub-shell with a hairdryer to facilitate an easier extraction of the bearing. The heat eventually softens Loctite or coaxial anaerobic glue that could have been used at the factory when the hub was first assembled.


Inserting a New Bearing
A new bearing should always be inserted by pressing it on the same race with which the hub bearing bore makes contact.
Cartridge bearings are generally fitted into the hub-shell with some interference on the outer bearing race.
In this case you have to press the bearing in by pushing it exclusively on its outer race. Pressure or hits on the bearing's internal race will permanently damage the new bearing balls and races.
To properly press in the new bearing it's necessary to use a special insertion tool (insertion tools are specifically made for each bearing size). Use only an inserting tool that is made for your exact bearing size.

Extralite offers a complete tool-set for hub maintenance: the Pro-tool kit 1 includes bearing inserting tools in every bearing sizes used on UltraHubs / HyperHubs.


Using an Old Bearing to Protect the New One
As a last resort you could use the old bearing to carefully press in the new one as follows (use this method for emergency only)
- the 2 bearings should be perfectly aligned
- the mallet should hit only the external race of the worn bearing
- tap the bearing down in small increments, rotating the worn bearing 120° each time, and be sure to keep it perfectly flat.
Remember that when you insert the hub axle has to slide into the bearings with only light hand pressure. Forcing the axle through the bearing will permanently damage the new bearing balls and races (the force amount is directly related to the bearing’s load capacity).


Hub Shell/Cartridge Bearing Interference Criteria
As general rule the pressing interference between hub-shell and bearing should be around 0.01mm. An interference of 0.02mm applied on a thin bearing (ex. 6802 - 6803 etc.) can compromise the ball-races tolerance match (on quality bearing's ball-races matching/coupling leaves less than 0.003mm of play).
If the bearing is pressed in with too high interference it can't rotate perfectly smoothly and will wear out prematurely.
The opposite case of a slightly loose bearing fitting can generally be properly dealt with using Loxeal 83.21 / Loctite 260 or equivalent products (coaxial couplings).


Hybrid Ceramic Bearings
The installation of Hybrid ceramic bearings is rather difficult and requires a very good expertise.
A proper bearing and axle insertion is even more critical when you are planning to mount hybrid-ceramic bearings. The ceramic balls feature a very hard surface that can ding the bearing steel races very easily. Additionally hybrid-ceramic bearings require a more precise tolerance match. Too much interference of the bearing outer-race with its hub shell fitting can often result in a rough-rolling bearing.The same thing can happen when the axle requires too much pressure to be slid into the bearing's inner-race.

Note: If your hub was originally equipped with standard bearings axle and bearing fittings will probably require micro adjustments of their fitting tolerances to allow proper bearing rotation and durability (these operations are for real experts only). Alternatively send your hub to us for this servicing.

Bearing Seals and Friction
Bearing seals are often the first resposable of bearing durability.
Tighter seals increase friction however do not over-estimate the effect. Actual bearing friction can't be judged statically by just rotating the axle with your fingers.
In the real use when the bearing balls rotate under load, they rub and rotate between races, which makes for much greater friction than a properly-fitted protective seal that could keep your bearings spinning smoothly for long time.
Good seals are really a must for
MTB use.
Bearing Durability
Bearing durability is related to a great number of factors such as seal type and conditions, use mode and frequency, environment, washing mode and frequency, hub maintenance and lubing and more, this makes each individual case quit different.
In highly corrosive environments the ceramic ball resists to corrosion and help to clean the hard steel races. In such circumstances the overall durability could be even higher than steel bearings but this is generally uncommon.

 


Ceramic Bearings

Bearing Friction
Bearing friction should be judged under load when the balls rub and rotate between races. In these circumsances the use of hybrid ceramic bearings can offer an advantage.


Today’s Quality Standards
Hi-end bearing manufacturers have now acheived much higher quality standards than only few years ago. Quality hybrid ceramic bearings are now made with incredibly hard steel races that can survive the coupling with ceramic balls for a much longer life.


Durability
The latest generations of hybrid-ceramic bearings, such as ABI Zero and HDC, offer durability comparable to a steel unit. Earlier generations of bearings could only offer a fraction of the durability of a regular steel bearing.
In highly corrosive environments the ceramic ball resists corrosion and helps to clean the hard steel races. In such circumstances the overall durability could be even higher than steel bearings, however this is generally an uncommon situation
.


Advantages and Disadvantages

Do not over-estimate the advantages of hybrid ceramic bearings. Their durability is equal or lower than steel ones, price is higher,all to gain a slightly lower rolling resistance.
When you are choosing to use hybrid-ceramic bearings be aware that the lower rolling resistance is the sole advantage they can offer besides a very very slight weight reduction (ca 1gr. less on each hub bearing).


Beware of Cheap Gimmicks

To enhance the feel of low-rolling resistance some non-serious manufacturer equip their bearings with non-contact seals and you can see them spinning for minutes- to your amazement.
Those bearings in reality last only few rides, as they collect dirt directly into their ball races and shortly thereafter require replacement (no surprise)
.


Full-ceramic Bearings
Among bike enthusiasts have tried to employ full-ceramic bearings in order to save weight and further reduce rolling resistance. Unfortunately with today's technology a properly dimensioned steel bearing cannot be replaced with a full-ceramic bearing of the same dimensions. Size should increase commensurately when moving from steel to ceramic and this nullifies any weight savings and requires a specifically designed hub-shell.
Additional note: even full-ceramic bearing manufacturers are openly not recommending their products for bicycle applications due to the ceramic material's fragility. Typical bicycle applications involve high impact resistance at low rpm (10-100 rpm) while the typical full-ceramic bearing application is at very high rpm (over 20,000 rpm) and absorbs only low impacts.

Load ratings of ceramics bearings
Ceramic has a modulus of elasticity higher than that of high carbon chrome bearing steel.
In the ceramic bearing, therefore, less deformation on the rolling elements (balls or rollers) generates higher stress at the contact point between the rolling element and raceway, when compared to a steel bearing.


Therefore, the contact stress between rolling elements and races of ceramic bearing would be significantly higher than that of steel bearing, under the same amount of load.

Bearing type
Dynamic load
Impact load
Hybrid ceramic
ca. 80% of steel bearing
ca. 70% of steel bearing
Full ceramic
ca. 80% of steel bearing
ca. 20% of steel bearing

Load ratings of ceramic bearings compared to steel bearings.


The load capacity of ceramic bearings is accordingly decreasing when working temperature is increasing. HSC suggests choosing a larger load rating capacity bearing when using a full ceramic bearing for your application. Due to the brittleness of ceramics, full ceramic bearings are not capable of withstanding too much impact load. The outer races or inner races will generate cracks or even suddenly break under a certain amount of impact load.

 


 Read Mountain Bike Action August 2007 article

"Ceramic Bearings 101: will they make you faster?"

Page 1 Page 2 Page 3 Page 4